Join our NEW Online Support Group for Grandparents & Kinship Caregivers!
Nov. 16, 2026

How One Grandmother Spent $10,000 Just to Be Heard

How One Grandmother Spent $10,000 Just to Be Heard
How One Grandmother Spent $10,000 Just to Be Heard
Grandparents Raising Grandchildren: Nurturing Through Adversity
How One Grandmother Spent $10,000 Just to Be Heard

Episode 139: How One Grandmother Spent $10,000 Just to Be Heard Every day across America, grandparents and kinship caregivers quietly shoulder the responsibility—and the heartbreak—of raising children whose parents cannot safely do so. This episode welcomes listeners to an honest, compassionate conversation that moves beyond simply surviving system trauma at the kitchen table. Instead, we’re taking the first steps toward advocacy in the boardroom—unmasking the realities of non-parental care, ...

Key Takeaways

  • Kinship caregivers like Ruthie Shofi often face systemic isolation, treated as administrative outsiders by local child welfare agencies despite providing round-the-clock stability for their grandchildren.
  • The financial toll of navigating the legal system can be devastating, highlighted by the reality that many grandparents must spend thousands of dollars simply to have their voices heard in court.
  • Upstream solutions—such as equitable Medicaid access, reliable financial stipends, and trauma-informed policies—are urgently needed to support relative caregivers rather than relying on their exhaustion to balance state budgets.
  • Moving from private survival to collective action is essential for kinship families to hold local and state agencies accountable and demand meaningful legislative reform.
  • Special guest and grandmother Ruthie Shofi's four-year battle on Maryland's Eastern Shore underscores the hidden economic and emotional costs borne by everyday relative caregivers.

Episode 139: How One Grandmother Spent $10,000 Just to Be Heard

Every day across America, grandparents and kinship caregivers quietly shoulder the responsibility—and the heartbreak—of raising children whose parents cannot safely do so. This episode welcomes listeners to an honest, compassionate conversation that moves beyond simply surviving system trauma at the kitchen table. Instead, we’re taking the first steps toward advocacy in the boardroom—unmasking the realities of non-parental care, demanding tangible economic and policy support, and empowering kin families to hold decision-makers accountable for meaningful reform.

Featured Guest Spotlight: Ruthie Shofi

While originally planned as a joint discussion, Amy Muchia (Founder, Grandparents United for a Change Nationwide) was unable to record due to illness. Amy’s tireless national advocacy, policy frameworks, and grassroots leadership directly informed the core themes, systemic audits, and legislative questions explored throughout this episode.

Connect with Amy Muchia & Grandparents United For Change Nationwide

About the Guest:
Ruthie Shofi is a grandmother and kinship caregiver living on Maryland’s Eastern Shore. With four years of firsthand experience navigating a small-town child welfare system, Ruthie has provided unwavering care for her grandchildren while grappling with faceless bureaucracy, emotional exhaustion, and the hidden economic costs of kinship care. Her story—marked by resilience, advocacy, and a willingness to speak hard truths—sheds light on how too many kin families are left out of decisions yet entrusted with the toughest work.

Key Episode Highlights

  • Expose the Hidden System: The conversation focused on how many grandparents, like Ruthie, are treated as outsiders by child welfare systems, even while serving as lifelines for children in crisis. Lived experiences reveal that kin are frequently left out of decision-making and struggle for recognition and support.
  • Reveal the Economic Toll: One concept discussed was the immense financial burden kin caregivers face—including a moment where Ruthie had to spend $10,000 on legal representation simply to have her voice heard in court, a cost that felt more like a paywall to child safety than a true investment in justice.
  • Demand Upstream Support: The discussion explored the urgent need for upstream solutions—Medicaid access, adequate housing, financial equity, and trauma-informed policies that put families first rather than relying on isolated, under-resourced caregivers who are too often left to absorb the system’s deficits alone.
  • Mobilize for Change: A key theme that emerged was shifting from private survival to collective action. Listeners are encouraged to understand their rights, ask hard questions, and join together in holding local and state agencies accountable for the real needs of kinship families.

Community Call to Action

Are you raising a loved one’s child? Have you been sidelined by the system or left to bear the responsibility with too little support? Share your story in the comments with your state and local county—add “rescue” to let fellow caregivers and advocates know they’re not alone. Forward this episode to another grandparent, kin caregiver, or ally who needs support, and keep demanding that policymakers recognize and respond to the realities of your family’s journey. Together, we can transform quiet struggle into collective action that has the power to change lives.

Send us Fan Mail

New! Grandparents Raising Grandchildren Online Support Circle! Starting Wednesday, October 7th, we meet every other Wednesday from 12:30 PM to 2:00 PM Eastern.

A peer-first, confidential space—free from cross-talk, judgment, or unsolicited advice. Guided by certified therapists, specialized family coaches, and counselors who truly understand kinship care.

I want to know how you’re doing. Is the podcast giving you what you need? What support are you missing most right now? Send me a Direct Message on Facebook or Instagram or email me directly at laurabrazan@grandparents-raising-grandchildren.org. I read and reply to every message because this community is built on supporting each other!


Thank you for tuning into today's episode. It's been a journey of shared stories, insights, and invaluable advice from the heart of a community that knows the beauty and challenges of raising grandchildren. Your presence and engagement mean the world to us and to grandparents everywhere stepping up in ways they never imagined.

Remember, you're not alone on this journey. For more resources, support, and stories, visit our website and follow us on our social media channels. If today's episode moved you, consider sharing it with someone who might find comfort and connection in our shared experiences.

We look forward to bringing more stories and expert advice your way next week. Until then, take care of yourselves and each other.

Want to be a guest on Grandparents Raising Grandchildren: Nurturing Through Adversity? Send Laura Brazan a message on PodMatch, here: https://www.podmatch.com/hostdetailpreview/grg

Liked this episode? Share it and tag us on Facebook @GrandparentsRaisingGrandchilden

Love the show? Leave a review and let us know!

CONNECT WITH US: Website | Facebook

"We are more than a " - Laura Brazan

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is Ruthie Shofi?

Ruthie Shofi is a grandmother and kinship caregiver living on Maryland's Eastern Shore who shared her four-year journey navigating a small-town child welfare system while raising her grandchildren.

What are the hidden financial costs of kinship care?

Kinship caregivers frequently shoulder massive financial burdens, including legal fees, out-of-pocket costs for child needs, and inadequate state stipends that fail to cover the true cost of raising children impacted by trauma and addiction.

Why do kinship caregivers feel excluded by the legal and child welfare system?

Caregivers are often sidelined in courtroom settings, kept at arm's length by caseworkers, and treated as outsiders or nuisances even while successfully providing stable, loving homes for children in crisis.

How can kinship caregivers drive systemic change?

Caregivers can move from private survival to collective action by understanding their rights, sharing their stories with state and local officials, and joining advocacy networks like Grandparents United for a Change Nationwide.

00:00 - Grandparents raising grandchildren struggles

07:09 - Coping with addiction and frustrations

11:00 - Taking in family members

13:59 - Daughter's involvement in court case

15:15 - The need for better legal representation

19:15 - Discussing human trafficking issues

22:45 - Advocating for kinship caregiver rights

Grandparents raising grandchildren struggles

SPEAKER_00

In today's interview, grandmother and kinship caregiver Ruthie Schaufi laid bare the brutal arithmetic of fighting an entrenched system. They told me I couldn't even enter the courtroom, she said. They had social workers in my house for a year watching those babies thrive, and then turned around to say reunification. Three weeks before court, my husband and I hired a lawyer for $10,000. And the day we walked into that room with an attorney, they didn't even contest it. That wasn't justice. That was a paywall on the safety of our children. Many of us have sat in that sterile courtroom hallway, staring at closed double doors while judges, caseworkers, and attorneys speak over our lives as if our sacrifice is an administrative footnote. When my husband and I took in our grandchildren, we traded our quiet retirement for midnight deprogramming, boundary setting, and bureaucratic runarounds that followed us from Montana down to Louisiana. We'd originally planned on bringing you two critical perspectives. One, Amy Mucia, founder of Grandparents United for a Change Nationwide, alongside Ruthie Schaufi, who's living the day-to-day survival on Maryland's eastern shore. But Amy's been under the weather, I'm sorry to say, and was unable to record, but her mission frames everything we're confronting today. For decades, child welfare systems have relied on us quietly, absorbing financial, psychological, and physical collapse in complete isolation in our homes. Today, Ruthie pulls back the curtain on what happens when an insular county treats relative caregivers like strangers. Welcome to Grandparents Raising Grandchildren, Nurturing Through Adversity. In this podcast, we will delve deep into the challenges and triumphs of grandparents raising grandchildren. As we navigate the complexities of legal, financial, and emotional support, I invite you to join us on a journey of exploring thoughts, feelings, and beliefs surrounding this growing segment of our society. Drawing from real stories and expert advice, we will explore the nuances of child rearing for children who have experienced trauma and offer valuable resources to guide you through the intricate journey of kinship care. We'll discuss how we can change the course of history by rewriting our grandchildren's future, all within a supportive community that understands the unique joys and struggles. This podcast was made especially for you. Welcome to a community where your voice is heard, your experiences are valued, and your journey is honored. Ruthie, so many grandparents and relative caregivers are stuck in survival mode. They're exhausted, you've spent your life savings, and you're treated like a stranger by caseworkers and judges. I posted a reel on social media and you responded. So I'd really like for you to tell us what your experience has been dealing with the systems with your case in your state and in your county.

SPEAKER_01

Laura, thank you again for having me back and the continuing work you're doing on this, you know, horrible topic, but important. Um, my case is four years with the grandchildren that I've dealt with uh in a small county. I'm in an area of 7,000 people. And it's all the way on the eastern shore end of Maryland. I grew up in Baltimore, but I've been here longer. But we're an area where the system the people in place have been in place for a long time. They don't want things to change. They're very difficult to get to. And they see these things that we are dealing with, with our children maybe being addicts or raising grandchildren. To a lot of the people I have to talk to, I'm a nuisance to them. They don't have like the time to hear, you know, what you really have to say to them. So for 20 years, I've been in the same small area with the same group of people fighting since my daughter's drug addiction began. Um and there's as anyone. I could tell you stories till we went to bed and woke up of the ups and downs. But what angers me when we talk about the county and the system and the people that should be there to help you, you know, I was like any mom, she was a very bad addict. And I believed everything when she would get in trouble, you know, don't enable them. Go to Al-Anon, go get help. And so therefore you back off, the county takes over. And today my daughter is in worse shape than she's ever been in. She is huge. Because of the county. Because of the county. They're they've put her where they put her. They um Where was that? They just in 20 years, uh, she's probably been in eight different homes. She's been in jail three or four times. It became a mastermind system for her to manipulate what she needed, as most people know addicts will do. Yeah.

Coping with addiction and frustrations

SPEAKER_01

And to play them was her biggest thing, you know, and to watch it happen because a lot of times she would have to come home while she was getting well. And, you know, if she had to see her probation officer that night she had high on whatever she wanted, you know, maybe for a couple days, because she had three days to get it out of her system. I know there's been situations where I took her to the hospital when she was pregnant and I knew she was using, and HIPAA was in the way. We've already gone through another baby and years of issues, so my frustrations would grow. But I know what's going on here. You know, let's fix this. Oh, but we can't talk to you. So it really would anger me.

SPEAKER_00

And I'm close to They didn't want your opinion, and they really didn't want to know what you knew about your daughter.

SPEAKER_01

No. I had watched I had walked into the bathroom three weeks before my middle granddaughter was born and found blood splatter. And, you know, I had just cleaned the bathroom, so I knew what it was. And she was out of it, and I took her immediately to the hospitals in a fit, saying, you know, she's getting ready to have a baby, and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. What's even more confusing again, and this is my personal, everybody has bad stories. She, before coming to live with me in the end of this pregnancy, had been living away from me due to a lot of stuff. But she was seeing a doctor that had that time put her on not Suboxin, but another drug. And I went and met with this doctor who reassured me that it was the best thing for my granddaughter and my daughter. And I mean, totally reassured me. And I'm asking her all these questions and her saying, Do you understand addiction? And I'm like, more than you would want to know. That grandbaby was born three weeks after I tried to take her to the hospital and no one would talk to me. Addicted and needed to be in the NICU for a few weeks. And she's wonderful. She's thriving, but she is a little on the spectrum. If you get her around sugar, it's it's ridiculous. She'll come back at you in five minutes like a true drug addict. It's a real issue.

SPEAKER_00

Well, we're aware, yes, we have a child in our family who's the result of a mother doing drugs and utero. And they're just different.

SPEAKER_01

Different, right? That it that's then we have labels and we'll get there one day. But right now that we know that it's different for us, right?

SPEAKER_00

So that's affected their brains and the way they process information. Absolutely. Cognitive issues.

SPEAKER_01

Fast forward, big time. You know, we're we're up and down. My daughter's living with the youngest baby. There was another baby born after her. The state's giving her $400 a month. She's getting $1,200 a month on a food card. They can go anywhere and use these food cards, as we all know. We're well known for steam crabs. And they could go to places and buy steam crabs. Chris could buy his own cigarettes at one time off of this food card. I think those things have changed. But, you know, there was a time when she would stand easily out in the parking lot and say to someone, you know, please, I need cash today. And if you would give me $50 cash, I'll give you $60 worth of food card. Call me when you get to the line and I'll come in. I mean, the ways they manipulated, the piano. And I'm telling my county, and it just was words. Words. You know. Um, again, I'm close to my senator.

SPEAKER_00

And you had the children at that time more than she had them. So she's getting the subsidies, but you're caring for the kids.

SPEAKER_01

I right now have a six, eight, and seventeen-year-old. When I got them, they were two, four, and thirteen. So the 17-year-old was the one that I had her on and off her entire life. But yeah, it was what did they do every time? They go back to them. Those are the systems, those are the words, these are the things, you know, and fast forward to four years ago when I got the kids, you know, the police

Taking in family members

SPEAKER_01

went into the house. They were in a manic state fighting all night long, and took my daughter to the mental hospital and brought the girls to me the next day, and they've never left my house four years later. And as you were saying in your statements and Amy, I became so frustrated that for one, we were family. I didn't just say I wanted to be a foster care person to hold. I think I might have looked at that different. If I signed up to say I have a home to hold a broken child, even though you know your family, it sounds so crazy, is broken until they bring you these children, they keep you so isolated from the world they were all really living. I didn't know half of what they had been doing because I didn't see them all the time. They didn't let me over. They don't have to be a good thing. But the system was in charge.

unknown

Yeah.

SPEAKER_01

They were giving them all these things, you know, this county.

SPEAKER_00

And and now do you get those subsidies or does your daughter still receive them?

SPEAKER_01

I get a a a food card. We do have a card, and it is four hundred and sixty dollars a month for all three children. And that's I get no help whatsoever. I was a full-time hairdresser for 42 years. I owned a salon and I had just closed it in 18 and then started to work at home a little bit and downsize. And as I shared with you previously, my husband and I wanted to start a food truck and take it down Florida in the wintertime when it gets real cold where we live. I as well marked for a hair brand. I had just gone to a huge seminar in September, just full of energy, you know. And two months later, you know, here came three grandchildren. And I can truly say, you know, as I do, I was in shock. It took me probably all three years to realize this is pretty permanent.

SPEAKER_00

But again, the And no support for the trauma that you had to go through, no help from the county or the systems to give you and your husband the emotional support that you needed.

SPEAKER_01

No, no, and that's what was even crazier to me, right? Because, okay, so fast forward, we're now at court. I have these kids for a year. I have the same social workers coming to my home every week. Some are picking them up. Well, no, not now, but this was when I got them, right? They're coming to check on them. My oldest one hadn't been in school for four months and she was suicidal. The two little ones needed doctor's appointments, and we were working. So they would send you all these social workers. I can get them to the appointments, I can pick them up. The help was like, oh my God, you had a team and you thought you were getting to a better solution. My daughter wound up in jail because of her neglect. The father stayed out there. He lost the apartment that week, and then he drinks a lot, you know. So I kept the kids. Well, fast forward because there wasn't anywhere for them to take them back to anyway. Now it's time to court. And they tell me, I can't go in the courtroom that the social warfer will go in with the oldest daughter. The two little ones don't go in at all.

Daughter's involvement in court case

SPEAKER_01

But that time the 13-year-old had turned 14. She was no part of the case. She was going to be with me no matter what. But she was speaking against them and the way that they had all lived. And I'm like, but what do you mean she's going to go in there on her own? And and they're like, oh, but we'll be there for her. And she has a lawyer. And I gave it my faith. I sat as all of us have out in that hall, or you know, just like, what's going on in there? What's being said? But all of that being said, they just kept me at arm's distance, right? And that was just to keep them placed longer. Well, now we're going to go to permanent court. And my daughter as well, they bring her back and forth from jail or a halfway house. Chris is drinking, losing jobs, but in a trailer, and he wants the girls back. Every one of these people that had been in my house for over a year helping me, watching what we were doing for these girls, how much they were changing and thriving and getting struck.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah.

SPEAKER_01

So we're saying to me, Well, when we go to court, we have to say reunification. And I'm like, What? He's like, What do you mean? There's nowhere to reunite. Where what are you doing? I I went ballistic. I'm sorry to use such a word. I I literally remember being like blacked out. They I would have probably felt the same way. Yeah. I'm sure most grandparents

SPEAKER_01

would. And they're saying you there's a lawyer for you, there's a lawyer for the children. I called each one of them. And that's when it really hit me how small my area was. Because they all work together, and every one of them, no matter what I said, they all agree with what I could say. But reunification. And that's when I realized they were taught they didn't have experiences. And I I no thought to them. And I thank them all for doing the work they do because somebody's got to get involved. But I'm at the same time saying, But you have to be more involved. You have to listen to the other side and involve us. Yeah. This is not fair.

SPEAKER_00

And I went But they listened to the father who's the drunk and taken from me.

SPEAKER_01

Jobless. And I mean, three weeks before court, my husband and I hired a lawyer for $10,000. And immediately when he went and got them papers, he said to me, He goes, Oh, they're mad because they know they're not going to win now. And people normally can't afford to do so. And I'm blessed. And we didn't have that money. It came from like where, right? A little bit of savings, maybe. But it was again priceless money. And in that day we went into court, every one of those, excuse me, lawyers said, Miss Shofi, they didn't even bring up what they threatened me about. And, you know, kiddingly, and I'm like, you know, I would have given you each a thousand and I could have kept a couple because you you knew the right answer. I mean, they didn't even contest it when my lawyer walked in that room with me at all.

SPEAKER_00

So it took the attorney to get someone less out of their the with money you didn't have that could have gone to those kids.

SPEAKER_01

Uh-huh.

SPEAKER_00

From another. And now that money could have been in a savings account for those kids in college education.

SPEAKER_01

Uh-huh. Yeah. And so it it's a really a messed up, broken system on so many levels. Again, you can't fault them because they're doing a job. None of them want to think outside the box. And I stayed hard on them and I do make them think. Um, the senator secretary would allow me to go to some meetings with the police department and the task force to express my opinion because I became so fearful. And then it all just fades, it all goes away. The addictions got better in our community, but not with my daughter. You know, she's now been released from the programs, but lives in town 10 minutes away on the beach with a friend, a guy. And again, uh you can edit out any parts of this because I'm not looking for shock factor. She is living with a guy who she has to perform favors for to be with because he doesn't have a special person in his life.

SPEAKER_00

And so he's obviously taking care of her financially in exchange for that. She still gets money from the state and her drugs from the state.

SPEAKER_01

They've pulled her teeth and she weighs probably 400 pounds, and they don't care a bit where her there they don't there's no motivation for her whatsoever. And I prey on it and I've accepted a lot, but it's it's sad. And I'm gonna share something real quick that's a good thing. Please do share it all, Ruby. Thank you. This past Friday we had an event in my town called TED X Butterfish Covey. This one young lady got up and spoke, and her name was Kim Kelly. This young lady was born into one of the most notorious cults in the world. She was raised in uh California, the children of God. Her mother was in that when it first started, her biological mom. She has four siblings from different dads. They were sent all over the world. She said, When you're raised in a in a place where you're taught that red is blue and there is no blue, as in the police are bad. There's your wall from the inside is up. And everybody out there is going to get you. You're homeschooled, you don't see TV. Everything is done in the name of Jesus in this cult. And this poor girl was born into this cult, escaped it on her own at 19. And now the only work she does is educating law enforcement on what it looks like from the inside

Discussing human trafficking issues

SPEAKER_01

for the kids that they're going after for human traffic and why they don't respond. And the biggest takeaway was we knew that if we ran away, the police were gonna find us. And what were they gonna do? They were gonna get us back. And we were, you know, all those things we've heard, but to hear her, I took my oldest granddaughter, who is now a senior and in criminal justice at the tech school and is studying human trafficking, is in an internship. She's doing amazing. I took her to meet her on Sunday, and we had a personal interview for 20 minutes. There's so much work to be done. But her biggest words were systems are broke everywhere.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah. Yeah. Thanks for sharing that story. Thanks for sharing your whole story. And the more grandparents that I speak to, and we're talking the statistics are everywhere from 2.6 million to 3 million families that are are coping with this dysfunctional system that isn't supporting our families from the very beginning. Support for mental health isn't recognized in families, boils down to that. You spoke about that conditioning that these kids get. These children that were raising were conditioned at the very beginning to have no boundaries. There brought many of them into the world with drugs in their systems, their cognitive abilities are destroyed or partially destroyed. And to recondition these kids to understand what somewhat of a normal life is, meaning boundaries, respect, self-respect, all of that takes so much work to deprogram them. And that's what you're talking about. We've had our kids for five years, and I'm teaching my granddaughter, I'm teaching her how to sleep through the night because she was never put to bed. There was no nighttime bedtime pattern. The parents stayed up all night doing drugs and partying and televisions were on and there was noise and lots of people around. So she can't sleep in silence. And she still gets up in the middle of the night. Her mind craves stimulation because she has, I mean, she has ADHD, but she doesn't know how to sleep in a quiet house. And it takes so much support to work with these kids that we've gotten, you know, because you have three of them, and we get no support. That's all we're asking for, some pretty simple things. I know that there are some new laws that are being passed in the state. I'm going to be talking more about them in the upcoming couple of months. It takes time. It's not going to happen in this lifetime, but it's good to know what our rights are. I never had to go into a courtroom for things like this before in my life. No, I don't know how to talk to a judge who tells me I can't speak. So we need that education and we need to know our rights. We're not just asking it for ourselves. When our lives are healthy and we know how to defend children, then their lives are healthier. In the end, the children are the ones that are benefiting. Thanks so much for sharing your story today, Ruthie. I really appreciate it. And just keep doing the great work you're doing and stay connected with the community that we have. Thanks, Ruthie. Thanks.

SPEAKER_01

I look forward to talking soon.

SPEAKER_00

Yeah, yeah, me too. Bye-bye.

Advocating for kinship caregiver rights

SPEAKER_00

Bye. I'd like you to take an audit of your situation as it stands today, not just the financial ledger where you may be bleeding life savings or scraping by on $400 food stipends, but your emotional ledger. Are you allowing an underfunded procedural system to treat your home like an unpaid holding facility while locking you out of the decisions that govern your grandchildren's lives? As Amy Muchia champions through Grandparents United for a change nationwide, we cannot shift policy by suffering in quiet corners. Stop absorbing the county's fiscal deficit on your personal sanity. If you've been told you aren't a party to the case or left to bear the physical and financial weight of kinship care alone, please drop rescue in our comments right now with your state and local county commissioner or state representative, and share this episode with a caregiver who needs to know their rights today. Join us next week as we continue breaking down the institutional barriers surrounding kinship families, analyzing the practical legal frameworks and grassroots action shifting the balance of power. The mission continues. We are 2.7 million strong, still nurturing and still here. The county relies on your exhaustion to balance its budget. But your home is an executive sanctuary, not an administrative dumping ground. So keep nurturing, keep leading, and I will see you in the next boardroom.

Related to this Episode

How to Fight Child Welfare System Barriers When Grandparents Are Locked Out

When grandparents step in to raise their grandchildren, they often enter a labyrinthine child welfare system that isolates them from critical decisions. This guide explores the systemic barriers kinship caregivers face—from courtroom lockouts to pro…